The Ultimate Guide to Creating the Perfect Pick ‘n’ Mix with Tyler's Treats

The Ultimate Guide to Creating the Perfect Pick ‘n’ Mix with Tyler's Treats

If you're anything like us, the words “Pick ‘n’ Mix” instantly bring back memories of standing in front of a rainbow of sweets at the local shop, deciding which sugary delights to scoop into your bag. Whether you’re a candy connoisseur or a sweet treat novice, creating the perfect Pick ‘n’ Mix is an art – one that requires just the right balance of flavor, texture, and nostalgia. At Tyler’s Treats, we’ve perfected the art of the Pick ‘n’ Mix, and today, we’re sharing our expert tips to help you create a mouthwatering selection that’ll impress friends, family, or even just satisfy your own sweet tooth.

1. Pick Your Base – The Classics That Never Disappoint

When building a Pick ‘n’ Mix, it’s important to start with a strong foundation. What are your go-to sweets? These are the classics that everyone loves, the ones that make any Pick ‘n’ Mix feel like a treat to remember. At Tyler’s Treats, we recommend starting with some timeless favorites like:

  • Jelly Beans: Brightly colored and bursting with flavor, jelly beans are a must-have for any Pick ‘n’ Mix. Their chewy texture and variety of flavors make them a crowd-pleaser.

  • Chocolate Drops: For those who like a bit of smoothness in their mix, chocolate drops (dark or milk) add a creamy texture that complements the crunchier candies. If you’re feeling adventurous, opt for chocolate-covered nuts for a satisfying contrast in flavor.

  • Gummy Bears: These squishy, fruity delights are an essential element in any mix. With their iconic chewy bite and sweet taste, they balance out more intense flavors and provide that satisfying pop of color.

Including these crowd-pleasers in your Pick ‘n’ Mix ensures that there’s something for everyone. But remember, variety is key – you don’t want to overdo it with any one type. Aim for a good mix of chewy, crunchy, and chocolatey goodness!

2. Spice It Up – Add Some Zing and Novelty

While the classics are important, no Pick ‘n’ Mix is complete without a few surprises! To elevate your selection and truly impress, it’s time to add some novelty and unexpected flavors. At Tyler’s Treats, we have a range of exciting, new-age sweets that will bring your Pick ‘n’ Mix to the next level:

  • Sour Candy: A dash of sour can give your Pick ‘n’ Mix the perfect kick. Sour worms, sour belts, or even tangy fizzy sweets (like our Sour Apple Slices) add a fun, mouth-puckering twist that contrasts beautifully with sweeter options.

  • Sherbet Dips: For a truly nostalgic feel, you can’t go wrong with a sherbet dip. This fizzy, powdery treat brings a little excitement to every mouthful, making it a must-have for those who enjoy a mix of flavors and textures.

  • Novelty Sweets: Looking to really impress? Try adding a few quirky sweets that might be new to your guests. Think Candy Popcorn or Lollipops with hidden surprises. These sweets provide both fun and flavor, and they’ll be the talk of the party.

Remember, the key to a truly unforgettable Pick ‘n’ Mix is keeping things interesting. The novelty items will provide conversation starters and make your candy selection stand out from the crowd.

3. Balance Is Key – Texture and Flavor Matter

Now that you’ve got your basics and a few surprises, it’s time to think about balance. A great Pick ‘n’ Mix isn’t just about throwing random sweets together – it’s about ensuring there’s a perfect combination of textures and flavors. You don’t want your mix to be all sweet or all sour; instead, focus on building layers of flavor that keep things exciting with every handful.

  • Chewy vs. Crunchy: Balance chewy, soft sweets like marshmallows and gummy bears with crunchy, bite-sized treats like chocolate buttons or toffee. A mix of textures keeps the experience engaging.

  • Sweet vs. Sour: A harmonious balance between sweet and sour is essential. Pair sweet options like strawberries and cream with a sour zing from citrus-flavored gummies or sour candy sticks.

  • Chocolate vs. Fruit: Complement creamy chocolates with fresh, fruity flavors. A touch of fruitiness, like our tangy Raspberry Jelly Beans or Blueberry Belts, provides a refreshing contrast to rich chocolate.

Once you have the balance of textures and flavors in place, you’ll have a perfectly harmonious Pick ‘n’ Mix ready for any occasion.

4. Tyler’s Treats – Your Go-To for Custom Sweet Creations

At Tyler’s Treats, we know that crafting the perfect Pick ‘n’ Mix is all about personalization. That’s why we offer a wide range of sweet options, from retro classics to modern, funky flavors that you won’t find anywhere else. Whether you’re treating yourself, hosting a party, or creating the ultimate gift, our variety of sweets allows you to build a truly bespoke candy mix that suits every taste.

We’re here to help make your Pick ‘n’ Mix experience as sweet as possible – so why not get started today? Visit our online store to explore all of the irresistible options we offer. Ready to make your own candy masterpiece? Head over to Tyler’s Treats and start building your dream mix now!

Call to Action

Now that you’ve got all the tips and tricks for building the perfect Pick ‘n’ Mix, it’s time to put your newfound knowledge into action! Head over to Tyler’s Treats and start creating your custom candy collection today. With a variety of sweets and treats, you’ll be able to build a mix that’s perfect for any occasion. Don’t forget to share your creations with us on social media – we love seeing your sweet masterpieces!

Sources

  • Sweets & Snacks Magazine

  • Candy Industry

  • National Confectioners Association

Let us know how your Pick ‘n’ Mix turns out – we can’t wait to see the delicious combos you come up with!

Back to blog